The Clouds is a 423 BCE play by Aristophanes, originally written in ancient Greek. At the time, professional intellectuals called sophists taught customers rhetorical techniques to use in public speaking, along with providing instruction in other subjects. In the play, Aristophanes satirizes sophists as teaching students how to be persuasive without regard for what is morally good, as seen when the character _____
Which choice most effectively uses a quotation from a translation of The Clouds to illustrate the claim?
Explanation
Context: The claim is that Aristophanes satirizes sophists as teaching persuasion without regard for what is morally good. The question asks which quotation from a translation of The Clouds best illustrates that claim.
Answer: D) Strepsiades hires a sophist to teach his son and says to the sophist...
Why? Strepsiades asks that his son learn the worse style of argument, "which, by maintaining what is unjust, overturns the better," and would drop the better one entirely: "at any rate the unjust one by all means." That is persuasive skill purchased with morality set aside.
Traps:
- A) The basket-and-astronomy quotation mocks an intellectual method; nothing in it concerns persuasion or morality.
- B) A father entreating his son to go and be taught says nothing about what will be taught or on what terms.
- C) Asking a new customer what he wishes to learn first opens a transaction and carries no moral content.